"A Gay Klingon?!": New Star Trek, Same Old Complaints - Steve Shives

[TexasTowelie]

- Historical hypocrisy: Critics today complaining about new Star Trek shows mirror the same backlash TNG faced in 1987 — objecting to changes like a bald captain, a female security chief, or a Klingon on the crew.
- Reactionary rage ≠ critique: Many online critics don’t offer thoughtful analysis — they nitpick superficial elements (e.g., “gay Klingon,” “skirt-wearing alien”) or project bigotry as if it’s valid criticism.
- Toxic positivity is also problematic: Uncritical fan cheerleading (“just enjoy Star Trek!”) ignores the franchise’s tradition of social commentary and thoughtful engagement.
- Demand for adult discourse: Steve challenges haters to critique like adults — with insight, articulation, and media analysis — rather than childish complaints or bigoted projections.
- Call to action: “Go ahead and critique it — but do it like an adult. We’re waiting… but not holding our breath.”

[Ray Bruns]

1. These are the people who are still complaining Captain Kirk kissed Uhura

[Xavier Breath]

2. In fairness, the bald captain was a step too far.