Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

General Discussion

Showing Original Post only (View all)

riversedge

(80,871 posts)
Fri Apr 3, 2026, 12:57 AM Friday

JUST IN: You do not fire your Army Chief of Staff in the middle of a war for no reason. You fire him because of what com [View all]



Shanaka Anslem Perera ⚡ @shanaka86
·
4h
JUST IN: You do not fire your Army Chief of Staff in the middle of a war for no reason. You fire him because of what comes next.

Pete Hegseth called General Randy George on April 2 and told him to retire immediately. The Pentagon confirmed it within hours. No reason was given. Not publicly. Not privately. A senior Army official told Fox News that Hegseth offered George nothing: no misconduct, no operational failure, no policy disagreement on the record. Just a phone call and a career ending in the middle of the most significant American combat operation in two decades.

George is the 24th general or admiral Hegseth has removed. But he is not the 24th. He is the one that matters. The Army Chief of Staff. The man whose signature sits between a president’s intent and the order that sends soldiers across a beach or into a tunnel complex. The 82nd Airborne is deploying right now. Marines from the 31st MEU are staged on the USS Tripoli. JSOC operators are at forward bases in Israel, Jordan, Saudi Arabia, and the UAE. Kharg Island, 90 percent of Iranian oil exports, sits 16 kilometres off a coast that someone will have to decide whether to approach. And the four-star general whose job it was to advise whether that approach should happen was removed 48 hours after Trump told the nation the war would continue for two to three more weeks.

The replacement is Vice Chief General Christopher LaNeve. He was Hegseth’s senior military aide before this appointment. The man who carried the Secretary’s briefcase now commands the Army the Secretary is reshaping. The chain of command did not break. It shortened. The distance between a television studio and a combat order just collapsed to zero intermediaries who were not personally selected by the man giving the order.

No reason was given. That is the tell. When someone is removed without explanation during a crisis, the explanation is the crisis itself. George either objected to something or was about to. The ground option. The power plant strikes. The Kharg raid. The escalation that turned a highway bridge in Karaj into rubble on the same day he was told to leave. Something in the next two weeks requires a chief who will not push back, and the Pentagon solved that problem by installing one trained as Hegseth’s aide.

A former Fox News weekend host just fired a four-star general with combat tours in Iraq and Afghanistan, replaced him with his own former assistant, and did it during a live war in which the next decision could put American soldiers on Iranian soil for the first time in history. No hearing was held. No misconduct cited. The Army woke up on April 3 with a new chief it did not choose, in a war it did not start, preparing for a phase the previous chief apparently could not be trusted to execute.

The question is not why George was fired. Every general in the building knows why. The question is what order is coming in the next fourteen days that required removing the one man in the chain of command who might have said no.

The war has no perimeter. The chain of command has no objectors. And the next phase has no one left to stop it.

https://open.substack.com/pub/shanakaans

?s=20






?s=20
23 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Why am I not surprised. patphil Friday #1
It's going to be a bloodbath. NH Ethylene Friday #2
That's my fear, too. calimary Friday #10
I'm am So Sorry, NH Ethylene.. Cha Friday #18
I'm so sorry Laurelin Friday #21
The Pisswig is still high over Venezuela dweller Friday #3
They are calling on new recruits Puppyjive Friday #4
OMGosh... does he have a choice Cha Friday #20
They haven't ordered him to go Puppyjive Friday #22
So Understandable why you or anyone Cha Friday #23
Illegal orders orangecrush Friday #5
Dumb-Fuck On Duty. BurnDoubt Friday #6
If dems ever regain the government this loathsome creature cannot just slink back to fox news LearnedHand Friday #7
Oh MAN!!! calimary Friday #11
Fascist playbook. I remember studying in college about all of the commanding officers that both Hitler and Mussolini KitFox Friday #8
Maybe this has something to do with it AverageOldGuy Friday #9
Every time I think maybe America is finally over this shit, calimary Friday #12
Sounds like what Trump would want done. wnylib Friday #14
It would seem Hegseth is trying to make sure KentuckyWoman Friday #13
Our entire government is in failure delisen Friday #15
It wouldn't surprise me if we someday add: Seinan Sensei Friday #17
What makes you think that hasn't already happened? AZ8theist Friday #19
Substack link does not work. BWdem4life Friday #16
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»JUST IN: You do not fire ...