Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

pat_k

(13,855 posts)
20. Another consideration: wealth undermines compassion
Mon May 18, 2026, 02:58 PM
Monday

The research is pretty clear on this: wealth undermines compassion.

And it makes sense. We evolved to share. Hoarding community resources -- which is basically what amassing great wealth is -- undermines basic parts of what it is to be a feeling, connected, being.

https://greatergood.berkeley.edu/article/item/does_wealth_reduce_compassion

We started doing research, and now we have real evidence. We’ve done studies where we measure activity in the vagus nerve, which extends from our brainstems to our abdomens. This nerve is the physiological nexus with compassion, and when it’s active most of us feel warm expansion, the feeling we get when we are moved emotionally. The more your vagus nerve fires, the more compassion you feel.

In one study, we showed undergraduate students of different backgrounds pictures of kids with cancer. Students from lower-class backgrounds had a high vagus nerve response. But we didn’t get much response at all in upper-class students. In fact, in every study we’ve done poorer people show a stronger vagus nerve response. To me, that’s tough proof.
...
Humans evolved to share. We’re meant to share, that’s how people survived in early hunter-gatherer societies. When you don’t share, you get tremendous social inequality, and that’s what’s going on today.

This inequality affects people’s health, and it affects our greater public health. When we study the emotional profiles of people from lower class backgrounds, there’s a lot of anxiety, a continual sense of being under threat, a sense of shame, a sense of being stigmatized. And that’s bad for your body and bad for your health.

But in this country, most of our political leaders—as well as those who influence them—are wealthy. And, in general, the wealthier they are the less interested they are in policies that help the needy.


Studies found wealthier individuals are more likely to cut off drivers in traffic, take more candy intended for children, and exhibit unethical behavior in experiments.




If Schopenhauer is correct in his analysis that compassion is the basis of morality, than a lack of compassion would be highly correlated with a lack of morality... and studies like those discussed above appear to support this.

Recommendations

3 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

My brother-in-law said this a few weeks ago. ananda Sunday #1
Because hording is a sickness Johonny Sunday #11
Their motto is "Only too much is ever enough." TheRickles Monday #14
It is not the answer that enlightens but the question. twodogsbarking Monday #15
Amen, brother. paleotn Sunday #2
Everyone should read popsdenver Sunday #3
Thanks for recommendation. Title (for us book nerds/library users)is one word, "jailbird." Timeflyer Monday #17
It has a special place popsdenver Monday #19
Thanks for this. My daughter calls it "enoughonomics." ancianita Sunday #4
Demand Nasruddin Monday #12
Please explain "demand for demand." I was just passing along my daughter's label for basic needs and minimal wants. ancianita Monday #18
I think prosperity begins with generosity and that is why Trump has to continue his grifts while he is Maraya1969 Sunday #5
I remember that story. Loved Catch 22, read it while I was involuntarily in the Army. surfered Sunday #6
I was young when I read, Catch 22, but that book had a profoiund affect on me, might have turned me from simple ShazamIam Sunday #7
I think that feeling made the TV show Mash so popular surfered Sunday #8
One of my favorite books. MLAA Sunday #9
When you have your health you have everything. mobeau69 Sunday #10
Perfect! Thank you for sharing this. I read and re-read my Kurt Vonnegut books. In "A Man Without A Country" one chapter KitFox Monday #13
I told my daughter when she was in middle school Danmel Monday #16
Another consideration: wealth undermines compassion pat_k Monday #20
Thanks for that link. progressoid Monday #23
Hits the nail right on the head. SupportSanity Monday #21
GOOD one. EXCELLENT is even better. calimary Monday #22
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Kurt Vonnegut tells a sto...»Reply #20