Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

FakeNoose

(40,914 posts)
13. I had read the book first, so I knew it was coming
Mon Feb 16, 2026, 02:49 PM
22 hrs ago

... I'm referring to James Caan's shooting scene.

But Robert Duvall - the Consigliere - he was a revelation in the first Godfather. Even having read the book first, I thought Duvall played the part so much better on the screen than he was written in the book. The audience expects Marlon Brando to dominate, and he did. But Duvall handled it and played off him in every scene they were in together. They were brilliant and the main reason it was such a great movie. In my opinion Al Pacino did more of a star-turn in Godfather II.

Rest in Peace, Robert Duvall, and thanks for all the great movies!

Recommendations

4 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Duvall sure could cowboy, too. Kid Berwyn 23 hrs ago #1
Lonesome Dove...one of my favorites of all time! RIP mtngirl47 22 hrs ago #11
Mine too Gak73 20 hrs ago #20
Open Range..... SergeStorms 22 hrs ago #16
He was one of the legitimately greatest Hey Joe 23 hrs ago #2
That performance as Boo Radley is underappreciated. ificandream 23 hrs ago #3
RIP maxsolomon 23 hrs ago #4
What a loss. DenaliDemocrat 23 hrs ago #5
Yes, DD Leghorn21 23 hrs ago #6
Not too many Godfather actors still alive. LoveSucky 23 hrs ago #7
Al Pacino is still around BumRushDaShow 22 hrs ago #8
I had read the book first, so I knew it was coming FakeNoose 22 hrs ago #13
Pacino was much younger than Brando or Duvall BumRushDaShow 22 hrs ago #15
I read the book, but was glad the film didn't include AdamGG 10 hrs ago #42
Didn't know he was still alive Yo_Mama_Been_Loggin 22 hrs ago #9
A great actor. milestogo 22 hrs ago #10
RIP area51 22 hrs ago #12
I loved/hated him in "A Civil Action". I kept forgetting I was watching an actor, not a real-life villain. eppur_se_muova 22 hrs ago #14
"" AllaN01Bear 21 hrs ago #17
One of the greats. R.I.P. OGBuzz 21 hrs ago #18
Duvall and Gene Hackman roomed with Dustin Hoffman BigmanPigman 20 hrs ago #19
Oh my gosh, I never knew that FakeNoose 20 hrs ago #21
While Duvall was uncredited they worked together in Copolla's The Conversation. pecosbob 7 hrs ago #44
I love the movie "Tender Mercies" IcyPeas 20 hrs ago #22
Oh, man........ Bayard 19 hrs ago #23
RIP mdbl 18 hrs ago #24
Of all the great roles he played, this is the one that stands out to me. Freaking iconic! wolfie001 17 hrs ago #25
Me too, He brought the Gung-Ho mentality in that moment. OAITW r.2.0 15 hrs ago #36
It's a key scene ... I hear different versions of this a lot! FakeNoose 1 hr ago #48
Answer FakeNoose 1 hr ago #49
I googled so quick I missed this wolfie001 41 min ago #51
Google is my friend sometimes: wolfie001 42 min ago #50
He had seven Oscar nominations and this movie was one of them..............The Judge in 2014 turbinetree 17 hrs ago #26
Another role he played nwliberalkiwi 17 hrs ago #27
He was one of our regular customers at a workplace years ago happybird 17 hrs ago #28
One of the Greats Sam I Yam 17 hrs ago #29
Damn.... Talitha 17 hrs ago #30
I loved him in secondhand lions srose58089 16 hrs ago #31
IMO the true measure of an actor MaineNative 16 hrs ago #32
One of my all-time favorites MissMillie 15 hrs ago #33
A great actor...in many films that made an impression on me. OAITW r.2.0 15 hrs ago #34
A sad loss, he will be missed JoseBalow 15 hrs ago #35
You get a two point conversion for the "Santini" reference. Prof. Toru Tanaka 7 hrs ago #46
A great loss Loisita123 14 hrs ago #37
RIP Mr Duval... electric_blue68 14 hrs ago #38
One of the best of our time. Upthevibe 13 hrs ago #39
He was the first to get into Major Hotpants pants as a god fearing Major Frank Burns tirebiter 12 hrs ago #40
So many good performances, but I love Secondhand Lions, and another movie called A Family Thing with James Earl Jones. HeartsCanHope 11 hrs ago #41
No knock on his acting abilities but... SamuelTheThird 7 hrs ago #43
The Outfit 1973...OG neo-noir classic. pecosbob 7 hrs ago #45
Loved all of his work. Rest in peace Robert. oasis 2 hrs ago #47
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Robert Duvall, All-Purpos...»Reply #13