Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Irish_Dem

(72,374 posts)
30. If you get a PhD you quickly learn how rigid and narrow the academic community tends to be.
Wed May 10, 2023, 06:51 PM
May 2023

Doctoral students want to conduct research on all kinds of topics related to their fields of study,
but their advisors and committee members slap that notion right out of their heads.

Yes I understand that scientific knowledge has to carefully and painstakingly built upon current and past knowledge.
And we cannot go off on tangents with no merit.

But there should be some wiggle room for people with vision and creativity.

Religion is a constant, iconic part off human existence. But we don't study it.
Why is it there, what purpose does it serve, is it hard wired in.

Just like love is an iconic part of human existence and there is not much research on the topic.
At least until more recently.

These are not seen as serious, legitimate topics in academic research.
So we just ignore some of the most innate, core parts of humanity.

Yes I agree, I think some of the things we consider nonsensical or woo-woo will turn out
to be perfectly normal human traits that we have yet to study and understand.

I think some psychic phenomena will turn out to have scientific merit.
Carl Jung believed in the collective unconscious, etc.
Which modern day physicists talk about, all things are connected.

In fact when I listen to theoretical physicists talk, they sound just like New Age experts.
Both seem to say a lot of the same thing.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

'Except for people's memories of me.' elleng Apr 2023 #1
+1 progressoid Apr 2023 #8
Thanks! Here's one with an orchestra in performance progree Apr 2023 #23
Thank you. elleng Apr 2023 #24
I don't know anything for sure, but evidence is on your side... dchill Apr 2023 #2
We as humans (generally speaking) have an inherent proclivity to SURVIVE Hugh_Lebowski Apr 2023 #3
When the tantalizing becomes the real... dchill Apr 2023 #13
I have had many experiences over the years BigmanPigman Apr 2023 #4
What happens is that the living will perceive 'signs' as a result of grief/stress Hugh_Lebowski Apr 2023 #5
"W know why we are here now" Why? nt Samrob Apr 2023 #6
Sorry that was poorly phrased ... Hugh_Lebowski Apr 2023 #7
This atheist agrees. Still. Why do we imagine a distant past? Why science, beauty, stories, love? ancianita Apr 2023 #9
When I was 16 I had a long conversation with myself about the soul. cachukis Apr 2023 #10
The only ones who know for sure..... joshdawg Apr 2023 #11
Actually there is some excellent scientific research on this topic. Irish_Dem Apr 2023 #12
Thank you!!!!! I've referred people to his writing before. Also, Your Eternal Self (which deals with Karadeniz Apr 2023 #15
Research by PhDs and MDs resonate the most with me, because I am a PhD Irish_Dem Apr 2023 #16
Since it seems to be hard wired in so many people Warpy Apr 2023 #20
Yes humans could be hard wired to have fantasy religious beliefs as a coping mechanism. Irish_Dem May 2023 #29
Okay, nothing wrong with 'no ruling anything out', being open-minded Hugh_Lebowski Apr 2023 #21
If you get a PhD you quickly learn how rigid and narrow the academic community tends to be. Irish_Dem May 2023 #30
Why didn't he win the Nobel prize? Farmer-Rick May 2023 #25
Because eastern religions already believe in reincarnation and have since ancient times. Irish_Dem May 2023 #31
Eastern Religions have no more proof or evidence than any other religion Farmer-Rick May 2023 #32
I see a lot of the same old reactions here. There's tons of evidence about the existence of Mind Karadeniz Apr 2023 #14
If one frees themselves from the bonds of time, Mr.Bill Apr 2023 #17
The list of things that humans once believed had origins in Gods and Magic is IMMENSE Hugh_Lebowski Apr 2023 #19
No offense taken, but that Japanese physicist... you know him... said there were eleven Karadeniz May 2023 #28
Well, if you got the evidence Farmer-Rick May 2023 #26
Memeory, likes and dislikes, outlook on life, all that stuff Warpy Apr 2023 #18
This is something that resonates (smiley face) with me Easterncedar Apr 2023 #22
I like to think when I visit my dead spouse's grave Farmer-Rick May 2023 #27
I don't want it ExWhoDoesntCare May 2023 #33
Latest Discussions»Alliance Forums»Atheists & Agnostics»My missive to a Friend tr...»Reply #30